Inside CR Test Labs: Sewing machines

One of the busiest spots these days in our Yonkers, New York, headquarters is a lab in which you'll find four people sitting among hundreds of swatches of cotton and bolts of chiffon, corduroy, and denim. They're not reviewing washing machines or laundry detergents but are diligently testing sewing machines for our upcoming report (see photo, right).

In early September—which happens to be National Sewing Month—the testers were making straight and zigzag stitches and buttonholes on cotton swatches to gauge ease of use for the machines. One tester repeatedly had to refer to the owner's manual, scratching her head as she tried to figure out how to use one of the machines. (Just like our readers, who have been clamoring for a report on sewing machines, our testers have varying levels of sewing experience.)

We're testing 18 different models, including some from brands your grandmother knew and one that's familiar to project-oriented fashionistas who keep an eye on the runway.

We're checking out mechanical and electronic machines, some with a foot pedal, others without. Some machines have automatic threaders, eliminating the tedious job of having to thread the needle. My vision's still pretty good, but an automatic threader seems a worthwhile feature.

One electronic model even has an LED screen that displays videos with step-by-step instructions. It's a lot quicker than reading a manual or calling your mom. Note that we conceal the brand and model information from testers so that they remain objective.

Our full report on sewing machines is scheduled for the March 2009 issue of Consumer Reports, on sale and online in February. Until then we'll keep you updated on our testing. To tell us what you're looking for in a sewing machine, post a comment below.—Kimberly Janeway

Essential information: Read our free buying advice for sewing machines.

Comments

[Annie]

What about repair history on sewing machines- especially some of the top of the line electronic sewing embroidery machines?? The price on some of these is getting close to the price of a small car especially when the "accessories" (necessary for the machine to embroider) are purchased. But do they work reliably and over time? So many currently available consumer comments on machines are shortly after they were purchased and not based on serious user experience or any substantial period of time for wear and tear. Also we can get repair histories on much less pricey items such as appliances, etc.
Would love to buy one of the new top of the line sewing embroidery machines, but have had such difficulty with the one I have, don't have the confidence to buy another...

[kari mccloskey]

haven't tests been done on which pellet stove would be the best to buy?

[Erin]

I love to sew, but what I'm looking for is a workhorse. My grandmother's 1940s (all-metal) Featherweight is still going strong (but doesn't zigzag), but the Swiss (all-metal) machine I've been using for most things and was given second hand has seized up for the second time and I'm planning to get a new machine for the first time in my life. I want one that will do basic stitches for clothes construction (straight, zigzag, buttonhole) well with plenty of power and speed control and one that I can quilt with if I'd like. I'd rather not have a computer and embroidery features only because I'd love a machine that will not be obsolete in 10 years. What I'm looking for is the best possible ease of use, control and stitch capabilities balanced with a machine that is built to last. I'm only sorry that the report isn't due out until March!!! It is so easy to get confused about machine features and brand reliability!!
If you review sergers I'd love to know your "simple serger" recommend too!

[Carol Ann]

I would like to see a report on quilting sewing machines. I have a 43 year old Singer Touch and Sew machine and I would like to update it but when I look at quilting machines there is just so many features that it can be confusing. My notebook is full of notes and I still have not made any decision

[JW]

I've been hoping for years and years for sewing machines to be tested so am thrilled to see this being done. The price range on machines is enormous, and some are very serious investments. If you are including the embroidery capability of many machines, then please address how to best acquire embroidery designs. Buying designs? From where? Buying software that allows you to create your own? What about just doing lettering? Etc.

The machine alone isn't enough - then you need something to embroider, and this is another potentially costly area to understand. There are lots of different options available, and no impartial source to evaluate them.

[Donna]

I hope there will be reviews for basic machines. My 18 year old granddaughter wants to learn to sew. I think a basic machine is
a great choice to learn on and will try to hold off buying her one
until I have your test results. My husband and I are long time
subscribers. We value your reviews and recommendations and seldom
make a purchase without consulting them. Thanks for the great job
you do for consumers.

[Ann]

We are looking for a reliable, inexpensive sewing machine model for a new sewing club at our high school. Need to purchase several so that the girls can get started. Any suggestions as far as heavy duty, reliable but relatively inexpensive makes/models?

[Rebecca]

Thank you!! I look forward to that review! I may just have to re-subscribe to read it. :) Thanks again!

[Renee]

I would love to see a review of the lower priced sewing/embroidery combination's. ($1,000.00 and under) A reliable and easy to use machine capable of the odd embellishment or monogram.

[mike deflavia]

Can you let us know anything NOW? I'm going to a sewing expo October 4, 2008 specifically to buy a sewing machine and have NO CLUE which one to get. Help!!!!!! Thanks.

[Helen K. Reitan]

First and foremost, I want a sewing machine that is easy to use. The automatic threader is an excellent idea - I am 66 and my eyesight is not what it used to be. I cannot thread the needle without some type of aid.

I have a really old Singer. When I take it in to be repaired and serviced, they always remark that the old Singers are the best. The new Singers don't last or cannot be repaired. I want a machine that is dependable, that can be repaired if necessary. So many of the machines are made of plastic that I wonder just how long they will last.

Button holes have always abeen a challenge for me. I have ruined more than one project because of the button holes. I am making bandana bibs for my grandson who has cerebral palsy. I would love to have a machine that allows me to put something fancy on the bandana.

[Kay]

I hope you're including a lot of different brands ... like Bernina, Viking, Janome, etc. I'm also interested in the embroidery units, as well as the sewing machines.

[Libra]

It will be interesting to see if brands/models that are price-fixed (ie: won't be discounted) are rated better than the rest. My 30 yr old serger (with a 10 yr warranty) was unrepairable. The new ones with the features I wanted were not sold at a discount unless you bought gray market (out of the country w/no warranty). I refused to play their game and bought the model I wanted used at a 60% discount. $2400 for a serger made in China with a 1 yr warranty was outrageous. Recently, I got an ad for a home embroidery machine machine that costs $10k without accessories! That's one expensive hobby. I can pay to have hundreds of items professionally embroidered for that price.

[Priscilla Huston]

I am looking for comparisons of sewing machines that are good for quilters, portable, and durable. I would like to see some pros and cons regarding the new computerized functions and information about features that may increase or reduce the useful lifetime of a machine. Information on locating and evaluating reliable maintenance would also be pertinent and appears to vary by brand.

[zanna knight]

I am interested in an intermediate machine for quilting and other household purposes. Automatic needle threader, thread cutter, up-down are essential, and some of the new featurss sound very useful. must have quilting foot, do button holes, basic embrodiery
(I'm thinking of names on quilts), some decent stitches. It must feed three layers of cloth thorugh and good stitching. I don't require tht it do thousands of stitches per minute. I good space between needle and right arm so it can hold a rolled queen sized quilt is also useful.

[Janet Ma'ly]

Since I posted a complaint about no sewing machine reviews, I just want to thank you for finally realizing this is a huge market and we really need your expert suggestions. Thank you so much!

[Sally]

Please give me any test results,brand reliability,etc for Baby Lock(BLQC2) and JANOME(MC6500P)I would greatly appreciate the help, I have to buy soon! Thank you.

[Diane Haase]

Finally--a review on sewing machines! Being a sewing machine fanatic--seamstress/collector I have 23 machines ranging from Viking 1+ to 222K to commercial Juki LU563, & many old gear-driven Singers I bought on eBay. I use most of them. What troubles me is how often manufacturers change designs and parts become obsolete and are not interchangeable even with similar models. Viking does this with their embroidery machines to the point that I will never buy another Viking embroidery machine. They become obsolete too fast. Is there a way you can incorporate some info on interchangeability on parts/embroidery cards, etc. among different model machines by same manufacturer? Also, some info on how well generic parts/attachments/cards perform compared to the originals?
Thanks!

[Glenda]

I would like to have a rating on how well sewing machines can sew through multiple layers of fabric. I would like to know how well machines perform as they travel over thick (multiple layers of fabric) seams.

[Karla Kizer]

I'm addicted to several online sewing websites, and beginners and intermediates (who plan to upgrade their machines) frequently ask for advice. Advanced sewers (not the plumbing-related variety) have often developed brand-loyalty and are better able to evaluate top of the line machines for themselves, and should probably get less of your time and attention. To help those who are new to the art and science of sewing, I'd recommend evaluating a machine based on reliably smooth straight-stitching (no puckered seams) on a variety of fabrics, decent-looking buttonholes (nothing is more discouraging than completing your garment with ugly, poor quality buttonholes), and the all-important ability of a machine to start stitching without creating a bunched-up bird's nest of thread. I hope you are testing the machines using different brands of thread with varying fiber content, too. Cotton, polyester, and combinations of the two produce differing results on different machines.

I'll look forward to reading the published results of your research.

[Jean]

I have been sewing for over 40 years. I introduce grade schoolers to sewing in volunteer programs and teach beginning and intermediate sewing to private students, mostly young women who've either seen their mothers sew or have had some sewing classes in school. Most of them have recently purchased a new or used sewing machine based on price (new machines) or name brand and price (used). And most of the machines are junk.

So, here's what I think sewers should look for when purchasing a machine:

1. Stitch quality. Consumer Reports has a good start on this. Basic straight stitch, zig-zag and buttonhole. CR tested these steps on cotton swatches. How do they work of slippery silkies, knits, heavy coat fabrics? The buttonhole stitch in particular should be tested on all of these fabric types.

2. How well do the feeddogs work? How does the machine handle different weights and types of fabrics? Does heavy fabric fit under the presser foot and will the feeddogs be able to move it evenly? Does lightweight fabric feed well or does it get drawn down into the machine causing jams?

3. What maintenance does the machine require? Mechanical machines must be oiled regularly according to the manual instructions. How easy is that to do? Can the user access oil points without using a set of screwdrivers to remove and re-attach faceplates and other machine parts?

4. What is the manufacturers warranty against defects? Does the buyer have confidence that they local retailer is knowledgeable about warranties?

[cidell]

I think you might want to consider categories for occasional sewing and for regular sewists. Yes, you can get a $100 machine from a big box store, but is it meant to be sewn on everyday.

Also, if Janome is making machines for Sears, you should tell us that so we can explore different price points.

[cide]

1. noise
2. number of stitches
3. automatic vs. 4 step buttonhole
4. Threading
5. feed dogs can drop?
6. Free arm?
7. Mechanical vs electronic vs computerized
8. Please don't lump in embroidery machines with general sewing machines

[Nancy K]

I am a garment sewer exclusively, I don't quilt and I don't embroider and I don't plan to. What I am looking for in a machine is ease of use, the ability to sew through many layers of denim or leather. I need a machine that can do great buttonholes repeatedly and do them on all kinds of fabric and do different styles of buttonhole. I want to be able to make them on garments where there may be uneven heights, like a placket or neckband. Even straight stitches no matter the kind of material. I would also like the ease of use features on the high end machines without having to pay for an embroidery unit.

[Susan M]

There are many issues one should look at when purchasing a machine. The type of sewing and your price point are the top two considerations before you look at brands and how they perform.

1. Will the machine go over 4 to 6 layers of denim (as in a hem at the seam line) as well as sew slippery silk without damage?

2. Do buttonholes have a professional apprearance? Is there a device or way buttonholes can be made on the center front of a garment where the buttonhole won't be distorted by the thick layers on a faced seam?

3. What machines work well for taking to classes or retreats or other travel? Do they suffer from the abuse of being moved about? Will they stay timed and in alignment? Is it small enough and light enough to be carry on luggage on a plane?

4. How is the stitch quality over time? Most machines seem to be fine when you first get them but over time the quality may change and you don't get as perfect of a stitch. Others start out with poor stitch quality. Define what that means and why the connecting of threads by the machine is number one for consumers with no knowledge.

5. Presser feet: What is standard with machines at different price points? Which ones are worth the money you spend on them? (Edge stitch foot, 1/4 inch foot, invisible zipper foot) Talk about the quality of feet and how they will last over tiime. In generic feet which are the performers and which are a waste of money either because of function or the ability to hold up over time.

6. How is the light, buttons/knobs, presser foot lifter, thread cutter, on/off switch quality, ease of use and placement? Are the controls intuitive or do you need to be an expert just to get the machine running?

7. Bobbin winder: Can you control how fast it winds? This can be very important on threads that stretch when you sew knits, fine fabric such as silk etc. A bobbin that is wound too tight might result in the stitches puckering the seams. Many people won't know this and think they have a problem with the machine not being able to handle finer fabrics. On embroidery machines, can you wind the bobbin without removing your work?

8. Embroidery machines: How easy is it to load a design, can it be modified (change stitch density for different weight of fabrics for example) easily. What different formats will the machine take and media type CD, USB, Cards? Perhaps talk a bit about different design houses and which are reliably consistant as well as price points.

9. Maintenance: The yearly suggested maintenance can cost $200 -$300 for a top of the line machine. In our area the mechanicals go for around $70/ year maintenance. Mechanicals can also be serviced by a knowledgeable sewist. Talk about parts cost, will they be available 5 or 10 years from now. When do you need to have a machine serviced by an authorized tech and when can you take it to your local SM mechanic.

10. Talk about different thread quality and how it makes a machine perform. Linty threads and slubby thread won't work well in TOL machines over time. I've found old mechanicals don't really care what thread you put in them, they will sew with anything.

There is plenty more but I am sure others will bring those points up.

[Melissa]

When you list the machine specs, also list the price of the following attachments to give the readers a general idea of how much they can expect for extra/replacement presser feet for the machine: walking foot, quarter inch quilting foot, and darning/free motion quilting foot. Please include the stitch width and warranty information.

Run the machine through some layers of denim and heavy weight fabric and sew for hours. We want to know which ones pop up with error codes that are not resolvable. Also give info on how long the needle threaders and thread cutters actually work.

[P. White]

New sewing machine buyers should know that the machines available from big box discount stores are usually limited in features, quality and reliability. They make work at first and for a short time but they won't hold up. You get what you pay for is very true in sewing machines. Buying from a reputable dealer that includes lessons and a warranty is smart!

All machines will do quilting, piecing of quilts and will also allow the user to construct clothing. There's really no need for differentiation of "quilting" or "non quilting" machines! Even a 1930s staight stitch Singer will "quilt"! The stitches are formed basically the same way in all machines, regardless of what you're making!

You should aim your reviews and recommendations to the new or lower intermediate sewer. Those of us who have been sewing for many years already know what we want and need in a sewing machine and many of we "old" sewers already own our personal choice of top of the line machines.

I've owned computerized machines for 20 years and have found them to be extremely reliable! They are much more "user friendly" than the old mechanicals. That said, they do have a higher learning curve and require more time investment to learn to use properly and to full capability.

[Lakisha Robinson]

I would like to know the actual manufacturer of the sewing machine, versus the "brand". For example, several of the Sears models are actually manufactured by Janome. When comparison shopping I would like to know that I can purchase the Sears model Janome, the Janome model Janome or the Singer model Janome machine.

[GlendaSue]

I am so excited you are doing a review on sewing machines!!! I have been wanting to buy one for over a year, but can't make up my mind. I agree with all the other comments. I am looking for a machine that can sew on fine light fabrics and I can also hem blue jeans on. I would like a quilting foot, self threading, up/down needle position when you stop, lots of attachments available.

Thank you so much!

[Jill]

I'm also looking to replace a 30 year old machine, subscribed to this site last spring when researching a vacuum cleaner, now I'm surprised you had vacuum reviews on here! I can't believe you've never reviewed sewing machines until now. Thanks a lot for waiting til February to reveal all.

[Marji]

I'm happy to see that you'll be reviewing sewing machines.
I'd be very interested in seeing a review of Sewing Machines independent of embroidery units - that IMO rates a category and review all on its own.
I'm guessing that most of your readership needing this information are newer sewers or those wanting to get into it, so information on how easy it is to trouble-shoot problems and fix problems without taking the machine in for professional servicing should be paramount.
Important elements: Stitch quality - balanced stitches, the ability to handle various fabrics without jamming, without skipping stitches, with varying weights of fabric. Buttonholes - both ease of making and consistency in quality.
Please compare lightweight machines to other lightweights, full size to other full-size, mechanical to mechanical and computerized to computerized.

[Jan]

I am thrilled that you are finally going to review sewing machines! It is THE reason I became a member. I wish it was going to be released before Christmas, though. I hope you cover all the aspects listed here - from workhorses to combination embroidery/sewing machines to quilting machines all in various price ranges.

[Barbara S]

Yesterday I received notice of my impending subsciption renewal. I decided not to renew since I hadn't really used CR that much this year. But since my sewing machine and I have had several disagreements as to who is in control of the fabric...I thought I would check out CR again. You know, one more review before I canceled my subscription. As I typed in "sewing machines," I remembered looking for serger and sewing machine reviews and being disappointed that there were none! Then I hit the "search" button and SURPRISE! I found a link!
I think Marji's (Sept 19)comments are an excellant summary of what most of us are looking for in purchasing any fabric handling machine. I anxiously look forward to your reviews.......guess you know now....I'll renew for another year. Thank you!

[m/m]

I suggest that you tell readers to try out machines if possible - bring along samples of what you currently sew (knits, quilt piecing, fine fabrics, thick fabrics, etc) and what you would like to sew. Try each machine out and keep notes. This is the way to go with the high end machines but hard if not impossible with machines from big box stores.

One of the problems with sewing machine reviews in the past has been that what's good for one type of user isn't good for another. Someone who wants to do lots of embroidery doesn't want a machine with the larger harp area that a quilter might want. Everyone has a hard time using an inferior machine but new users might not know enough to realize that it's the machine's fault, not theres. Lots of people have problems with machines simply because they haven't threaded them right or they're using the wrong size needle, a poor quality needle, or the wrong thread (weight, content) for the job. Projects often fail because so much of the fabric that's easily available is of poor quality too.

You might want to do a comparison chart - 4 step button hole or automatic button hole/feet that come with the machine/stitches the machine does/lessons from the dealer or not/guaratees/computerized vs mechanical/quality of directions & threading directions on the machine, etc.

You really should include some info on thread, needles, and similar things for people who are new to sewing to get them started. There's also a huge online community out here where people can go for help - Patternreview.com, American Sewing Guild, magazines and websites like Taunton Press's Threads and their "gatherings" board, etc. Also there are classes at adult schools, schools like Fashion Institute of Technology in New York City, at independent fabric shops, etc.

Just buying a sewing machine isn't enough for a beginner.

Then you've got sergers, long arm quilting machines, cover stitch machines, all of the embroidery machines, ... you're just hitting the tip of the iceberg!

Feels good to get this off of my chest and am looking forward to the article next year.

[Elaine]

I think several people have already covered the gamut of information you could cover in this review. I'm so excited to hear your are testing sewing machines. I'm new to the craft, and like so many others, I rely on your input before making most of my purchases. Can't wait for the final review is available.

[Ana]

Can the machine sew a variety of fabrics--not just cotton swatches--Almost no one wears gingham dresses anymore. Does the fabric feed smoothly or does it get stuck under the foot? Are the feed dogs so rough and the foot pressure so heavy that fabric gets damaged? Is the foot pressure adjustable? That makes sewing modern fabrics easier. Prove the dial works--measure it for us. Fleece is popular. Can you get three or four layers under that presser foot while keeping them lined up enough to sew?

Is the lighting adequate? Can the machine be used by someone with less than perfect vision or dexterity?

Does the manual cover the essentials? Theading? Buttonholes? Adjusting needle thread tension and bobbin thread tension? Is it actually accurate? Seriously. Some manuals arent. Does the manual tell you how to oil and clean the machine or does it take the lame way out by ignoring the issue or having you to bring it to a dealer?

How expensive are accessories? Does the edge foot cost $45? What about the stitch-in-the-ditch foot? 1/4 inch quilting foot? All popular but rarely included.

Can it make good buttonholes? Can it make 8 good buttonholes in a row that all look the same? Some buttonhole issues arent fixable by the user, sometimes techs cant fix them either.

Can it make a smooth looking satin stitch?

How hard is it to sew over a bump? Or through thick fabric? I dont want to hem jeans by hand when I have a sewing machine.

Can the machine sew slowly? If you try to go slow and the machine just whines then lurches ahead at full speed, thats disconcerting for beginners and annoying for the rest of us.

Are all the stitches usable? My machine claims to have 40 stitch functions. Most work well. 4 are completely useless--including the buttonhole function and the lightning stitch, because the adjustments available dont actually fix their problems. 2 other stitches just tear up and mangle the fabric--thats any fabric, any time.

Is the machine noisy? Does it bounce? Does it smell like heated plastic? Is the cord extremely short?

Can the machine be repaired? Where? Do you have to ship it?

Thats what I want to know.

[David Gross]

My wife is interested in a serger.

[LaWana McClary]

After weeks of comparing all the sewing machine brands, I decided to chose Bernina. Bernina's website makes it easy to choose between the different models. There is a category for sewing and quilting, and one for the embroidery machines. I knew that I wanted to make apparel, quilts, and other home decor. Because I have four granddaughters, I also knew that I would also like to embroider. So I selected the Auroua 430.

This system is ready to upgrade to Bernina's Stitch Regulator(BSR), which is a quilter's dream. This presser foot allows you to quilt in free form motion, creating your own design, or just to guide the foot into a series of swirls and loops, just whatever!

The Aurora 430 is also adaptable for the embroidery module, which allows you to embroider and personalize.

For me the Aurora 430 was the best option, allowing the purchase of the sewing machine with the option of adding the BSR and/or the embroidery module later.

[SL]

In addition to the other comments, a little discussion of the pricing of dealer-only machines would be helpful. Buying a sewing machine is sadly worse nowadays than buying a used car because the companies require dealers to keep mum on the price, and you can't comparison shop on the internet except for lower-end models. Buying a machine is a game of who can bargain the best; for high-end machines some people pay over $1000 more for the same machine than someone else with better bargaining skills. Perhaps if more people knew and complained about the secretive pricing, the manufacturers would give in a little on their protective pricing policies. I bought a machine used and sacrificed getting a dealer warranty just because I didn't want to haggle over prices.

[Lori]

Thank you for doing a review on sewing machines! Besides "ditto" on all the above comments, please make sure your testers use the machine as a consumer would depending on what they want to do with it. Quilters, embroiderers & garment sewers all have different needs and preferences in machine features! Besides that, more experienced or demanding sewists will probably want a higher quality & sturdier machine with more features where a person just learning to sew may do very well with a simple & less expensive machine to start off on.

Accessories for machine like feet or other attachments for special purposes are also important to consider. Do the feet/attachments work as intended without thread breakage or other problems? Are they designed well & easy to use for the task?

Please have your testers do more than sew a few sample seams & buttonholes on different fabrics. It would be great to have them make an entire project start to finish so they can get a real feel for the machine & how it handles so they can give a complete evaluation. Examples of what I mean are: For garment sewers have them sew something with sleeves, collar & a zipper; how easy does the machine handle around curves? For a quilting test they could sew a baby size quilt or wall hanging. For embroidery they could actually embroider some RTW garment to evaluate how easy the machine allows the design to be positioned,& does the machine have a USB connectivity to allow easy transfer of designs to/from a PC.

Please also compare ease of handling & capabilities of machines that have a 5.5mm versus a 9mm stitch width!!

Thank you very much for your upcoming article & for considering all the input from sewers!

[Nancy Plough]

I would like to see some info. on sergers also. For many the two can go hand in hand. I am upset that I cannot find any information, but am encouraged that CR is testing them currently. Thank you.

[smhnana]

We want a basic machine for garment sewing--straight stitch, zig zag, zippers, buttonholes. Able to handle different types of material, knit to heavy denim. We want a practical, economical machine--just basic skills with DURABILITY AND DEPENDABILITY. So tired of new machines that break easily, do not last, and cannot be fixed! Thank you!

[Carol-Ann Gilbert]

w! Finally, sewing machine reviews to come. I have e-mailed several times requesting an updated report on sewing machines which, I believe, were last rated about five years ago. As other readers mentioned, just happened to log on and was thrilled to see that it is in the works.

The categories I would be interested in are:

Ease of use;
Noise;
Quality of stitches (through several thicknesses and all types of fabric, including thick denim, leather and slippery silks) (reiterated by many readers);
One-step (fast and easy) buttonholes, superbly repeated for all 4, 6, or 8 holes on garment; (making it look professionally made);
NO tension irritations (I have always had problems with this);
Info on less expensive embroidery machines (i.e., under $1,000.);
ACTUAL manufacturer's name (an excellent request by one of your readers).
A good, reasonably priced and reliable sewing machine that will give me a choice of wonderful embroidery capabilities, if I so desire, be it an electronic machine or simply an embroidery machine.

Can't wait until February!(wish something was available sooner).

[Carol-Ann Gilbert]

w! Finally, sewing machine reviews to come. I have e-mailed several times requesting an updated report on sewing machines which, I believe, were last rated about five years ago. As other readers mentioned, just happened to log on and was thrilled to see that it is in the works.

The categories I would be interested in are:

Ease of use;
Noise;
Quality of stitches (through several thicknesses and all types of fabric, including thick denim, leather and slippery silks) (reiterated by many readers);
One-step (fast and easy) buttonholes, superbly repeated for all 4, 6, or 8 holes on garment; (making it look professionally made);
NO tension irritations (I have always had problems with this);
Info on less expensive embroidery machines (i.e., under $1,000.);
ACTUAL manufacturer's name (an excellent request by one of your readers).
A good, reasonably priced and reliable sewing machine that will give me a choice of wonderful embroidery capabilities, if I so desire, be it an electronic machine or simply an embroidery machine.

Can't wait until February!(wish something was available sooner).

[Susan Smith]

I hope the review covers warranty loopholes. I found on a new Bernina that labor is not covered, and that the warranty is valid only at the dealer where you purchased the machine, making it useless and costing me almost $300 to repair my 4 month old Bernina 630.

Another area to include in review is the cost and inclusion of accessories and feet.

As indicated above, the secrecy and no-compete associations of the high end independently owned dealerships of the high-end sewing brands should be mentioned. Trying to find out the price of a machine was a huge hastle! The dealers won't give you prices, the manufacturer doesn't publish or disclose their suggested retail prices. They use their refusal to give a price as the bait to get you into the shop to give you a hard sell. Used car dealers are actually better to deal with than the sewing machine sales people!

[Susan Smith]

I would like to see information on the warranties included in the review. I've found out after spending $300 on a repair on a 4 month old Bernina that labor isn't covered. The Bernina warranty is only good at the dealer where you purchased the machine, which doesn't really make it a sound warranty, or wasn't to me anyway.

I also the review should cover the practices of machine dealerships not publishing or providing a MSRP over the phone. My experience buying a sewing machine was much worse they buying a used car!

[Rick Schell]

The test plan will cover 18 models. From which manufacturers?
Singer and Kenmore (of course)... I would recommend these manufacturers - Husqvarna, Viking, Bernina, Brother, Baby Lock, Janome, Pfaff... there are so many more. Is 18 models enough?

The test plan could easily include 10 manufacturers and 40 models.

But thanks so much for taking this on. I'll take what I can get now and hope for annual updates.

[Hugh Ivory]

This is ridiculous. I signed up for the online info so I could buy a sewing machine now, and then find out that I have to wait six months to get your evaluation. Don't you have any recommendations available now?

[KH]

Please- Serger Info! It is so hard to find any info on sergers, short of the manufacturer's spiel. It seems that people who chat about sewing online are mostly embroiderers/quilters, so no one compares or contrasts serger machines. I sew apparel! I would like to sew knits with ease and grace! (not to mention a balance left in my bank account...) As a loyal subscriber, I know Consumer Reports can help me ;)
I'm delighted that you're testing sewing machines- Thank You!

[Erin]

I do quilting and other thick, multilayered projects and would like info on sewing machines that allow the presser foot to be raised extra high...higher than the standard setting. Today I looked at a Pfaff Quilt Expression 4.0 which has this feature, but the machine is on "sale" for 2500.00 (after trading in my old Singer). Thank you.

[Vicky Terrell]

Please include sergers!

[Tina Winkley]

I (anxiously) look forward to your review. We blindly trust your recommendations and are so appreciative of all that you do.
I would also like to read about your evaluations of quilting machines. I've just joined a quilting group with my 20 year old JC Penny model at my side. I think it's still kicking as it didn't see the light of day for 15+ years. The instructor of the course suggested a model, but I will patiently await your findings. Thank you!!!

[Christine]

As another person mentioned, the manual as very important to your success as a new or intermediate sewist. I have a machine w/ a useless manual and have wasted a great deal of time trying to figure things out on my own.

I'd also love to read about stretch stitch availability and quality on the machines since I sew polarfleece, cotton jersey, and elastic frequently.

[Mary Louise]

I too am frustrated that the results of your test won't be available until February. Does it really take that long when you're only testing 18 models to post the results online? Would it be possible to post the results online any sooner? Will you also be looking at the amount of vibration that occurs when sewing at high speeds? My experience over the years has been that lightweight machines vibrate excessively when run at high speeds.

[Lucille Clark]

I have recently had a terrible experience with a machine, the company that made it and the repair shop that supposedly repaired it. I am in the market for a new machine and would love to have your report on computerized machines. I do alterations but hopefully soon I will be able to discontinue that job and do what I love...sew, especially heirloom clothing for infants and toddlers. I need a machine that has the qualities to do such fine sewing and speciality stitching. Sewing on fine fabrics such as handkerchief linen, Swiss Batiste and silk call for a machine with a light touch but strong stitches. Also the company policy on repair. (Brother has only one authorized repair shop in the entire state of Georgia!) I look forward to the report in 2009.

[Tricia]

I understand the change in sewing machines is prolific but so is the change in cars. I've been subscribing to CR for a number of years an am glad you're finally getting around to rating them. My need it now and I'll have to search elsewhere. I can't even the your old review anymore. Once the review is posted will I have to add the magazine to my subscription to view it? I'm confused by your recent changes?

[Lynn]

I am looking into a Brother 4500D vs Janome MC 11000. I would appreciate knowing ASAP if you have tested either of these brands and if so would you also know what their ratio is for repairs. I would appreciate any information you could send. Thank you for your time and consideration.

[Melissa]

I'm getting frustrated with my older Singer mechanical machine. I've only ever used a Singer, and this is my second. I constantly seem to have issues with the thread tension, birds nests, broken thread, etc. I have sewn many different garments and types of projects, so I am not necessarily a novice, though I haven't had many classes (just an old home ec class in junior high). I have tried changing the needle, adjusting the tension according to the instruction manual, oiling and cleaning the machine, re-adjusting the bobbin and re-threading the machine. I'm getting so frustrated and can't figure out if my problem is with the machine (do Singers just have these issues?) or if I am doing something wrong. Since it goes from being fine to having a problem, I suspect it is the machine.

I very much look forward to seeing your report. I hope to see reviews that include any issues that certain brands have, the best brand for reliability, repair costs, and cost-effectiveness. I enjoy sewing and hope to do more in the future, but every time I have a project and the machine starts messing up it really sours me on the whole thing. I'd definitely like to see some more in-depth information that is broken down by the kind of user using a machine, as in if it is ideal for a beginner/occasional sewer, intermediate, expert, etc. as well as the strengths that each machine has.

Thank you so much for your service on behalf of consumers. I'm anxiously awaiting the published results!

[Heather]

If you want to review what CR is looking at, read their article that I've posted. You'll find an answer to a lot of your questions there.

[Tom]

I want to buy one for my wife, know nothing about them but do know what features she really wants. I don't really care what I have to pay for a good machine, but would really like to make sure price of more expensive machines is justified in quality, reliability, ease of use and service.

[LoriAnne]

I've been sewing since I was 8,now I'm in my late 40's, I learned to sew on my mothers Singer. I own a Kenmore, and the only thing I have problems with on the machines I've used over the years is that they don't or can't handle several layers of or bulky materials. I'd like a machine that won't get bogged down when I work with a heavier fabric. Thanks!

[Emma]

I do a lot of sewing and have started to embroider in the past few years . I purchased a basic embroidery machine and lately have been having problems , I've had it serviced and no improvement. I am considering purchasing a more expensive unit( and some are very expensive ) . I hope your research will help me make the right decision.

[Elaine Dunbar]

To the person who commented on stretch stitches sewing knits or fleece fabric, I use a fine zig zag stitch and have achieved excellent results. I find the stretch stitch very hard to remove if I need to do any adjusting to my stitching.

[Elaine]

I am looking for a good machine for quilting and need a stitch regulator. There are different kinds on the market and they are all very expensive. I am interested in ease of use, reliability, cost, support, and warranty. Thank you for finally reviewing sewing machines - I just wish it were sooner!

[Rachel]

Like many other individuals, I am looking for a machine that can handle a variety of tasks such as occasional sewing projects, home decor, repairs, etc. But one thing I was surprised to see very little comment on was the need for a machine that can handle papercrafts as well (scrapbooking, cardmaking, etc.) I have had great difficulty finding any reference to machines that can accommodate these projects. This is a growing market and many papercrafters are desperate to find a machine that can handle this function effectively. Any info would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

[Karen R]

I just started looking for a new machine. My current one is a 1972 Singer that does a few decorative stitches, works very well for most sewing, and obviously has lasted forever. It's going to wear out pretty soon. My concerns are the quality of the electronic components (the cheaper they get, the lower the quality, the less dependable they are), the sturdiness (as one person above said, from jean seems to fine fabrics) and the cost of the options. I'd like to be able to do fancy decorative stitches, but am not willing to spend $4000 to do so.

Karen

[Suzanne]

I sew for residents of
a home for the disabled. Many
different projects, from mittens,
to special pillow cases, and creating
special washable bags for tracheotomy
tubes...and covers for headrests..
Now I really need to get a
SERGER. I'm hoping you can recommend
a really sturdy and strong SERGER
to help me complete many of these
projects without having to sew over
seam allowances so many times. HELP!
I'm sewing with my 2nd Bernina...an Activa 240
purchased only last year. My first
Bernina is 32 years old and still running
great...I just needed to update....
It's a great reliable sewing machine.
...computerized, but I don't have
to download anything.

[Margaret]

My advice to anyone new to sewing - If at all possible, take the model you are looking at for a test drive. Remember when you learned how to drive? It will get easier, and like driving, it is much easier if you have someone to show you the ropes. Try to talk to someone who sews that isn't going to benefit from your decision. If you just need a reliable machine for mending, you may find someone willing to sell you a used machine. If you don't know anyone that sews, the clerks at the fabric store can sometimes steer you to people who can help you. If you are truly new to sewing, definately put some time into shopping around and talking with people that sew. The cost of a machine can leave you living with your decision for a long time.

Try to be realistic about your needs. I love the look of embroidery but I don't think I would use it very much. I know how to embroider by hand, so I decided that was not a priority. I love textured fabrics, so consistantly even stitches through different weights and textures was high on my list. I love to do patchwork, so I wanted a machine that could accelerate, slow down, corner, reverse, and stop on a dime.

I know sewing machines can be very intimidating. I love to fix things around the house and use hand and power tools. There are machines that are simple and machines that are more complex. Are you able to look at a manual and make sense of following the directions? If not, you may want to buy from a dealer that will give you free lessons with your purchase. I have been sewing for 40 years and recently bought my third sewing machine. I asked friends and family for their experiences with reliability of different models, tried some out, narrowed down what I was really after, and spent $1500.00 on a model I am very happy with and that will hopefully be the last one I ever have to buy!

Make a list of what you want, and what you need, how much you can afford. If you still are having trouble, waiting for that March issue that reviews different models would probably be a good idea.

[Joanne]

I also thank you for doing a review of sewing machines, but wish it could come out sooner to help me with buying a Christmas present for this year. Someone may have already mentioned this, but it would help if you would ask for input from those with machines already to do a repair/user satisfaction history, and publish those results as well.

[Cora]

Thanks for coming to the rescue of home sewers!!! I'm interested in a sewing machine that makes great, hassle-free buttonholes on a variety of fabrics - wool flannels, heavier coat fabrics, shirtings, denims, corduroy, velveteens, etc. Preferably --1)a buttonhole that can be adjusted for width so you have enough space to cut it down the middle and not cut the buttonhole stitches and 2) a buttonhole that doesn't require a lot of fussy attachments to make it. Attachments often come loose and have to be readjusted after each buttonhole. That's a nuisance!

[Martha]

I am looking for a basic lightweight machine with good stitching for taking to classes. I have a good machine at home Bernina 1230.

[Deb]

I'd like to see information on children's sewing machines. I just bought one for my 6 year old and she loves it, but it is really awful quality-wise. However, we only paid $10...

[TK]

Could you speak to any machines that might be "upgradeable", or start with the basics and allow more complex tasks to be added (embroidery or specialized stiches).

Can it be upgraded in any way?

Lighting on sewing area

Self-threaders, thread-cutters, up/down needle

How many feet and which feet are included.

What options are included or available for specialty sewing (i.e. hoops for embroiderers, knee-lifts and walking feet for quilters, etc.)

Dealers offer trade-ins? how much.

What service is available in which areas

What "name" carries the lowest price-point among similar models

How does it handle cheap (big box store) thread

Thanks for doing it, like another poster said, I now have a serious reason to a>renew my membership ang b> defer buying a new machine until after your report comes out. I look forward to it.

TK

[Anne White]

Looking for something to sew French Seams in leather.....

Sick of my current machine--which has never worked properly..

HELP!!!!!

[Kim van der Veen]

I'm on my third sewing machine in 3 months - all of them have broken. I'd like Consumer Reports to look at the durability of the new sewing machines - especially the many plastic parts that seem to snap, break, and gouge.

The March reviews aren't coming soon enough for our business and our home, each of which need a sewing machine.

Please keep posting early results for those of us in a 'bind.'

Thanks.

[LYNN LA MATTINA]

IN 1983, MY HUSBAND BOUGHT A VIKING 6990 SEWING MACHINE FOR ME. IT WAS JUST TUNED UP AND I WAS LOOKING FORWARD TO DOING LOTS OF SEWING, HAVING JUST RECENTLY RETIRED. HOWEVER, WITHOUT WARNING, I HEARD A "POP" FROM THE MACHINE, AND IT BEGAN TO SMOKE LIKE CRAZY! AFTER 25 YEARS OF USE, THIS OLD FRIEND OF MINE HAS DIED - BECAUSE REPLACEMENT PARTS ARE NO LONGER AVAILABLE. I AM THRILLED THAT CONSUMER REPORTS IS GOING TO GIVE US AN ARTICLE ON MACHINES, AND WAS VERY IMPRESSED BY THE NUMBER OF WONDERFUL COMMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN SO THOUGHTFULLY POSTED TO THIS SITE. I,TOO, REALLY NEED THE INFO NOW, BUT WILL MOST LIKELY DELAY MY PURCHASE UNTIL YOUR ARTICLE IS PUBLISHED. I HAVE BEEN ADVISED FROM MY DEALER THAT SINCE ONLY THE HIGHER END VIKINGS ARE STILL MADE IN SWEDEN, I MIGHT AS WELL CONSIDER THE LOWER PRICED BROTHER BRAND - ALSO MADE IN CHINA, LIKE MOST OF THE VIKINGS. I AGREE THAT THE REPORT SHOULD FOCUS ON MACHINES THAT ARE USEFUL TO FOLKS WHO ARE LOOKING FOR A NON-SPECIALIZED MACHINE, PERHAPS REPORTING ON MORE SPECIALIZED SEWING MACHINES IN A LATER ISSUE.

[ACK]

Your review on Sewing Machines cannot come soon enough for me - I almost threw my current machine out the window about 5 minutes ago, thus my search for reliable reviews on sewing machines.

Please include information for a sturdy, affordable, all-purpose machine. By that I mean a machine made for everyday sewers:

1)Sews thin window-shear material without "eating" the fabric
2)Sews hems in denim jeans (multiple thick layers)
3)Easily does button-holes and zippers
4)Is easy to thread (both bobbin and needle)
5)Is easy to adjust stitch length
6)Is easy to adjust the foot for fabric thickness
7)Basic stitch selection (straight, zigzag and maybe a few other special stitches - I don't need 50 stitches!)
8)Good lighting
9)Inclusion of all necessary tools to do the above basic things - such as attachments, a decent number of bobbins, and a clearly worded and diagramed manual.

What I wouldn't give for my parent's old Singer tonight!

Thanks for doing the reviews - I only hope that I can hold out until March.

[Sandra Pittman]

I want to find the best sewing machine for machine quilting. The machine would need a wide area to lay the quilt on and should be able to handle a fairly thick quilt "sandwich." I also want a machine that makes machine applique simple--one that makes stitch width adjustment easy. I like the look of machine embroidery, but I don't think I would use it much.

[cheryl lennig]

I would love to know which sewing machines (besides very exp. bernina) will sew on leather. I found out the hard way that my Viking does not. Also, repair history is very important in any purchase I make.

[Elizabeth Nicol]

I would also like to find a recommended machine with serger capability. That is a true time saver.

Other issues of interest:
* ease of maintenance
* service access and quality
* repair history
* expected wear and tear- how many hours can it go before it dies?

Thanks!!

[Mamalov]

I need a sewing machine which will work easily and well on garments made of silk, chiffon, cotton, knits, or wool and which will also do heavy duty sewing such as slipcovers, canvas items, etc. Is there such a thing?
The requirements listed above are all essential and I thank the writers for posting them, but I haven't seen anyone mention the really, really heavy duty stuff. Please include this in your testing. Thank you!

[Laura]

Not everyone is a quilter! I want a machine for garments using very high-end fabrics, some of which can be a challenge to work with, e.g. chiffon, velvet, various silks, extremely light cottons, knits in various weights, leather and very heavy wool. Sometimes I combine different weight fabrics in one project. And I also will be sewing over several sewn layers of varying thickness. I need a machine that is not sensitive or finicky regarding tension. Even simple projects can be a problem for tension. I think Husqvarna has a machine that automatically adjusts the tension itself. Is that so and are there others? Can they respond to varying thicknesses?

Finally, durability, ease of use, reliability and reasonable repair/maintenance costs should be the bottom line of ANY purchase.

Asking too much? I hope not!

Thanks very much and I can't wait!

[Ruth]

Like many of the above commenters, I have sewn for years. My current sewing machine and serger can handle most things, but perennially my problem is heavy!! material - naughahyde, fake fur, heavy fleece and denim - and I need a machine not so much with fancy-dancy embroidery and computerized stiches, but one that has a heavy pressure foot. Someone above quite rightly said no one wears gingham dresses any more but the real issue is the new kinds of fabric that we use to sew with.

I, too, am anxiously awaiting the report, but I feel experienced sewers only need apply for the job of testing. Any "big-box" store machine will do great for the inexperienced. I'm looking for commercial strength in a home machine. Good Luck.

[Leslie]

I'm wondering about sergers. How does one decide between a regular sewing machine and a serger, and what to look for if you decide a serger is for you (or break out a section on sergers, as you appear to be doing for mechanical versus electronic).

[Dixie Redmond]

I own a Bernina 1080, which I purchased in 1993. I love the machine, but the power supply has an issue after all those years of sewing on it. It's been a great machine. I use my machine weekly, but to be truthful, I use the basic stitches most of the time - straight, zigzag, buttonhole, sometimes a utility stitch here or there. I want to know who is making a machine that I will still be using in 20 years? I want a workhorse. But I am definitely interested in a self-threading feature. :-)

Dixie

[Erin]

My machine that I've had since I was 12 is on its last legs, so I am thrilled you are doing an article on sewing machines and I look forward to the March 2009 issue. I want to be able to sew through thick fabrics like several layers of denim or velvet with buckram. I also would like some stiches meant for knits. I would like some embroidery capacity, but I am confused about what is available.
Also, I have wondered if you have software to change an embriodery design on your computer, what happens when you update your computer? Does the software still work? Thanks again, Erin

[velvetgirlgjqs]

Hi, I'm glad for two things -
1 - that consumer reports is taking on sewing machines,
2 - there is a real need for this information, as with the price of clothing our families have gone to ridiculous heights, some people are still enamored with making quality garments and really need some assistance!
I have sewn in the past, but my husband is looking for a new "hobby" and we looked at a computerized, embroidery/quilter - it looks great to me, but what is the down side? Will it be upgradeable for at least 5 - 8 years? Is it repairable? What is it's reliability and does the manufacturer stand by its product?
It is great to have information on "basic" machines, but will this report have the "high-end" machines in it also?
Thanks so much for having this blog and allowing "real" people to have a say in this testing!

[Ana Marie Romero]

My seven-year old granddaughter wants to learn to sew. Although she is a bit younger than the recommended eight year minimum, I do believe, with adult supervision, that she will be able to learn. Which machine would be good for a child?

[Kathryn McHenry]

As a graduate in Textiles and Clothing, I am hoping that you will include machines that perform their BASIC functions well, i.e. maintain even stitch tension and ones that will easily handle several layers of fabric, heavy fabrics and suede. I could care less about fancy embroidery, but will be looking for a machine that features a good basic overcast stitch. I have used Consumer Reports services for years and always rely on their ratings when shopping for new appliances, etc. I plan on purchasing a new machine when your March ratings come out!

Thank you.
Kathryn

[Nancy Harper]

I have two different brands of high end embroidery machines. My biggest questions is which embroidery software is the best. Since several of them cost as much as 2,000.00 I would like to know which ones are the easiest to use and what all they offer. I am wanting to digatize and stitch out my own designs. How good is the digatizing software and the output?

Hope you add the evaluations of software that comes with these brands since they are so expensive. It really makes a difference. It will be so hard to wait until March for all this info.

Thanks
Nancy

[Jazzy Jaz in Hawaii]

Looking for a sewing machine compatilble to the RICCAR, which I have had for the last 30 + years. Completely mechanical, parts are cast metal, which means less breakdown, and no wear on mutilple usage on heavy fabric. Most of the distributor, such as Discount Fabric Wearhouse can sell and service, but they could not give me information on how it is build, plastic gears for cast. I need some input, if any one can give me some information. Baby Lock has a BL -9 , REALLY basic, what about the Baby Lock call NATALIE, how does it hold up to heavy usage?

HELP!!!!

Jazzy Jaz in Hawaii

[Carmen Clarke]

I would like a mention of the option of buying old reconditioned machines. I had the opportunity to buy a Necchi, but was discouraged b/c of the scarcity of replacement parts. What is the market like for used machines? Is this a good option, given the availability of good inexpensive machines on the market?

[Val]

When our home burned down in April 2007, I lost my electrified (treadle) Singer, used for denim, thick fabric, layers, etc; my Kenmore 100 stitch (20 yrs old) and Singer 4 thread serger. I was planning to buy an embroidery machine in the middle of their price ranges but I lucked out there! I will be replacing one or two depending on your ratings. I need an embroidery machine and am very interested in a computer aided design machine although it's probably out of my budget. I can do without a serger but with my Kenmore I was able to personalize and embroider my father in law's name on clothing in his nursing home. He rarely lost anything! Now I have 2 new granddaughters and I would love to monogram and embroider ready made and homemade clothes for them. We really need a comprehensive look at all price ranges, low to high, and as many brands as are commonly found out there. I agree with other posts, auto-threaders are extremely useful and it's especially important to review sewing on a variety of fabrics--weight and fiber content--and throw in a bit of info on thread! Maintenance, warranty and repair centers, manurfacturer of store branded machines is also helpful. I will be taking my own fabric samples with me, dark colors and test drive one if possible. Tear-away tissue for very lightweight fabrics was helpful when I learned to sew during my freshman year highschool but i would hope today's machines would be a lot better! I've owned several metal gear/innards machines over the years and they were superior to the plastic gears in today's machines. Please let us know structurally if the machines are well built! I used my Mom's Necchi for years and it rarely needed service. If i still had it, I would probably try to find parts or a machine online and have it repaired. I hope you take all the suggestions to heart and give us at least 2 reports on different performing machines a year!

[Tracy Monroe]

My main sewing lately is patching blue jeans. I'm looking for a machine that will sew straight and zigzag stitches, frontward and backward, and easily sew through denim. I bought a $100 Singer from Wal-Mart a couple of years ago, but it isn't really heavy duty enough for the denim. I hope Consumer Reports can guide me toward a good one soon!

[Pam Wagner]

Thank you, thank you, thank you!!! I've been waiting for sewing machine reviews from Consumer Reports for a long time. I'm in the market for a quilting/embroidery machine (or just a quilter...not sure yet). Please include repair histories/quality, etc. It would be most helpful to know about all price ranges because some of the newer embroidery machines are $8,000, while some models are only about $3,500. That's a very broad price range. Does one pay the higher prices just for the "cadillac" name brands or are the lower priced models just as good and reliable? And, all pros and cons will be greatly appreciated. It's a jungle out there so any help you can give on these machines is most helpful. Thanks, again!