« Opioids for relief of chronic pain? Try less risky treatments first | Main | Q&A: Liquid vitamins—better absorption? »

April 14, 2008

| More

Help yourself: Learn how to rate and manage pain

Pain is the main complaint for about 40 percent of patients visiting primary-care doctors with roughly half of the people with chronic or recurrent pain failing to get adequate relief. In many ways pain remains a medical mystery, but here’s what to do for occasional, severe, and recurrent pain:

Self assess. First, assess how bad the pain is. Rate it on a scale of 0 (no pain) to 10 (the worst pain you could imagine). For pain that you rate 5 or less, start by self-treating with nondrug measures. For example, use heat to help ease back pain or cramps. You can also use over-the-counter pain relievers, which typically suffice for this level of pain.

How to choose an over-the-counter. Choose a drug based on the type of pain and your risk factors. Acetaminophen (Tylenol or generic) is often a good option. At recommended doses it's reasonably safe and effective for most people. People who drink heavily or have a liver disorder should avoid acetaminophen, since it's toxic to the organ. Ibuprofen and naproxen are often good over-the-counter choices if acetaminophen isn't enough. They not only ease pain but also quell inflammation. Both drugs are probably safer than aspirin, which poses a higher risk of bleeding. And while long-term use of any NSAID poses serious gastrointestinal and possibly coronary risks, the short-term use of recommended doses is generally safe for most people who don’t have heart, kidney, or stomach problems.

Severe-pain solutions. If you rate your pain at 6 or higher, it doesn’t improve with nondrug steps and OTC drugs, or it lasts longer than a few days, see your doctor. He or she might suggest a prescription NSAID, because a different or stronger formulation may yield additional relief. Another approach can be a prescription opioid such as oxycodone (Oxycontin and generic). You or your doctor might resist using such drugs because of addiction concerns. But physical dependence typically requires several weeks of use, and psychological dependence in patients with acute or severe pain is unlikely because they rarely experience euphoria from the drugs.

Medications that pair an opioid with acetaminophen, aspirin, or ibuprofen may be an even better choice. Those can provide greater relief, since the two ingredients work in different ways, and they reduce the risk of side effects because the combination permits smaller doses of each.

Recurrent pain. Even when the pain is relatively mild, chronic or recurrent pain from arthritis, headaches, or other sources can seriously interfere with everyday activities. Since chronic pain often ebbs and flows, rating your discomfort on the 0 to 10 pain scale can help you decide, day to day, how to manage the problem.

For more information, see Consumer Reports’ Best Buy Drug report on opioids.

Comments

Kat, I know exactally what you mean about the emotional, physical, and social problems arising from chronic pain. I have had chronic pain since I was 14, I am now 25. I have been to so many different doctors to try and find out what is wrong with me or some way to help me get through the pain and get fixed. The closest thing they can figure is Fibrmyalgia even though I do not have the specific tender points. The Dr. said that you don't have to have them, especially because so many of the other symptoms fit. I have struggled day after day for over ten years and I still do not see an end in sight. I have been through so many medications it's ridiculous people can say a med name and I think oh I know what that is I took it...I currently take medication, that helps, but still does not make me feel good or even great. I really wish I could find a Dr. that would actually invest in me to really find out what is wrong and help me get better. I have gotten my hopes up in the past only to have the dr. tell me 2 years later that there's nothing else they can do, and it was a pain management dr. I have went through the problems of having people think I am makeing it all up or it is all in my head, because all of the hundereds of tests I've had done come back normal. But trust me no one would want to make this up it is painful. And what is even worse is that some of the procedures I had done ending up making me worse. A lumbar punch and later blood patch gave me pain from my hips down. It is very hard to carry on certain day to day things, but I can give hope to some that you can make it and go far. I graduated top 3% of my high school class, graduated from Texas A&M. It was very hard at times but I did it. I do have bad times where I can't function day to day very well, but I also have days that I do good. I really wish if anyone has anything to suggest or even maybe a support group, because I really think that would help to be able to talk to others with the same problems. I would really appreciate it. And to consumer reports Thank you for all the help, from the health guide website to the pushing for the government to do things. I really hope you continue to delve into the medical issues a lot more in the future and become a place people can come to for true and unbiased facts and help. We, chronic pain and fibromyalgia, need all the help we can get, so we can get the help we need. I also would love to see someone or some group compile ratings for dr.s because it is so hard to find a good doctor and it costs a lot of money to go through lots of doctors to find a good one. I could def. add my comments to that list. I think that wuld be a wonderful asset to all people. I would actually love to do it myself but i have no idea how to do it or where to start. :)

Hi! Good article. Thanks.

I had a two level lumbar spinal fusion with instrumentaion in 1/2003, and had the instrumentation removed in 11/2003 due to continued pain and muscle spasms. The second surgery did not did not stop or reduce my low back pain as hoped.
I tried many other drug and non drug therapies prior to and after my surgeries including; a TENS unit, steroid injections, physical therapy, ice, heat, capsacin creme, NSAIDS, anti-convulsants and anti-depressants. I also was a evaluated by a chiropractic doctor who declined to treat me after seeing my MRI.
I now use the generic fentanyl patch for pain relief. It reduces my pain from a regular 7 - 8 to a 5-6 using a scale of 1 to 10. Some days are worse others better.
For me, the unappealing fact of physical dependence and risk of tolerance are worth the benefit of pain relief that the patch provides. To be brutally honest I do not know how long I would find the courage to face every day without the prospect of pain relief. It wears you down physically, emotionally, and socially.
I hope science provides a better way. I do feel lucky that I have this medication as I know of others who suffer either because they will not take it or their doctor will not prescribe it due to a well meaning but ill informed fear addiction.

I have pain that comes and goes due to Thoracic Outlet Syndrome which causes pain in my neck and shoulders plus Osteoarthritis in my hips,knees,elbows and spine. I had read that creams usually don't help much but I tried Aspercreme and it does wonders in a few minutes! I only use it when I have discomfort and it's gone in a few minutes, plus I don't have to worry about overdosing like with pills. Now after taking fish oil for about three months,I rarely have any discomfort, have they done studies on fish oil and pain?

On the subject of wrong meds, I use Vaniqa, which is for reducing facial hair for women. The last time I ordered some, they gave me Vanacream (which is for babies, I think) I took it back and said this it the wrong product and the young man did not even check the record, he just argued with me and insisted it was the right product! I had to go to another window and talk to another person to get it exchanged!

I have long term pain management for arthritis. Be sure to question the doctor or pharmacist when a new medication is prescribed. These medical providers do not (actually in my case- seldom) check to see what you already are taking- especially from other doctors. I was prescribed a new medication that contained a drug I was already taking. The doctor did not tell me to stop the medication I was already taking, and as a result I overdosed and ended up in the emergency room. Also be sure to read the information that comes with a new medication (although this information is not easily understood by the patient).

As a pharmacist who dispensed thousands of pain pills every DAY, I strongly recommend attempting non-drug pain relief such as heating pads, yoga, meditation, muscle rubs, TENS units, only take the pills when you truly need them, and avoid doctors that will write anything you ask for.

According to a study posted in Hepatology journal, acetaminophen (Tylenol) is a factor in HALF of all liver transplants!

KEEP YOUR MEDICINE LOCKED UP! I talk to patients everyday that have their medication stolen by their children or "friends."

For six months I participated in a drug study for the combination of Tramadol Ultram and Mobic for the treatment of arthritic pain. The study was to last for a year, but was cut short when the drug company deemed it would not be profitable to continue.

I was stepped down to half doses for a week, then completely cut off from the Tramadol (I continued the Mobic because I had been on that prior to the start of the study). I then entered in to a very intense, agonizing period of withdrawal from the Tramadol.

I ended up in an urgent care facility where I was prescribed ambien and advised to take it with benedryl so I could get the sleep I'd missed the previous three to four days due to the Tramadol withdrawal.

I offer up my story as a caution to anyone considering a prescription pain killer. Don't make my mistake which was not to research the drug and ask informed questions before taking it. I was told the drug was not habit forming. I was not warned of any withdrawal symptoms.

Please, do your research. Seek non-pharmaceutical ways to manage your pain before even considering medicating yourself. However, if you have no other choice, be informed, ask questions and don't let your doctor brush you off.

Post a comment

All comments are reviewed by our moderators, and will not appear on this blog unless they have been approved. Comments that do not relate directly to the blog entry's contents, are commercial in nature, contain objectionable or inappropriate material, or otherwise violate our User Agreement or Privacy Policy, will not be approved. Approved posts generally appear within 24 hours of receipt. For general inquiries not related to this blog, please contact Customer Service.

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Consumer Reports Health Blog Archives

-    November 2009
-    October 2009
-    September 2009
-    August 2009
»    View All
 
We create unbiased health ratings to help you make informed decisions. Learn more
FREE Newsletter
Sign up for our FREE updates delivered by e-mail.