Ratings: All-in-one and regular printers

Need a printer to go with your new desktop or laptop computer? We’ve updated our printer Ratings (available to subscribers) with all-in-one and regular models. You can spend as little as $50 for a regular printer (that prints very good photos and text, fast), as long as you don’t mind that it’s very much a no-frills model with no LCD viewer, no PictBridge connection for your camera, and no memory-card slots. Or you can shell out close to $300 for an all-in-one that faxes, copies, scans, and prints excellent photographs. But there are also plenty of models in between.

Whatever you decide, give a little thought to what you want to do with the printer before you buy it. Do you print a lot of text? Look for a model that can churn out seven to 10 very good or excellent pages for less than four cents per page. If you want to add faxing, copying, or scanning to your printer’s capabilities, check the all-in-one Ratings.

If you’re a photo buff, look for a print time of under two minutes for a 4x6 photo. Consider the tradeoffs if you want to save some cash: For example, some lower-cost models might print average-looking text, but still perform very well printing photographs.

More importantly, make sure you choose a printer with low photo-printing costs. The best of those we tested will provide excellent photos for 35 cents apiece. And if all you want to print are snapshots, check our Ratings of snapshot printers. The Recommended models print 4x6 photos for a quarter each.
Don’t forget to look for extra features like a separate tray for 4x6 paper, or automatic two-sided printing. Also take a few minutes to view our video on choosing a printer.

—Donna Tapellini

PMA2008: Two serious printers for serious photographers

HP and Epson, as well as other printer manufacturers, showed a variety of printers, from the very inexpensive snapshot models to very large-format models costing thousands. Two in particular caught my eye: The Epson Stylus Photo R1900 (right) and the HP Photosmart Pro B8850 Photo (below). (Click on the images for a closer look.)

The pair have several things in common. Both were announced in January and are targeted at the advanced amateur, one who most likely owns a digital SLR and wants to get the most from those photos. Both can print up to 13- x 19-inch prints (or longer panoramas). They each use an 8 pigment-based cartridge system, as opposed to a dye-based one, since the longevity of pigment is supposedly twice as long. Both are priced around $550. And from the specs and product demos, both offer quite a variety of printing options that will be quite exciting for most any photographer, from the ability to print on paper of varying texture to traditional black-and-white prints.

One of the improvements on the Epson R1900, the successor to Epson's R1800, is (according to Epson) enhanced gloss in the ink, making it much smoother than the R1800's gloss coating. The ink set itself has also undergone an overhaul: the new Ultrachome Hi-Gloss 2 ink set now includes a new red and orange cartridge, which Epson says offers more accurate facial color tones. Epson's also says that it has improved the printer's speed, which can now produce photos (in the highest quality mode) from 37-41 percent faster than its predecessor. Among other improvements on this model are two USB 2.0 ports. (The new HP printer includes one port.) The R1900's highest resolution is 5760 x 1440 dpi.

The HP Photosmart Pro B8850 Photo printer (left), which has a maximum resolution of 4800 x 1200 dpi, is roughly the same size as Epson's R1900, although a bit heavier. Like Epson, HP claims that its new-pigment based inks are more water-resistant and resilient than dye-based inks from previous printers. HP claims to have a better color system for handling black-and-white prints, since it includes not only matte black and photo black ink cartridges (as does Epson), but also a light gray cartridge (Epson does not have a gray cartridge).

HP also said that they've worked with Adobe and other software companies to make the B8850 (and its driver software) integrate more seamlessly with image editing programs like Photoshop CS3. For many photographers, color management can be tricky and time-consuming HP claims that they've reworked their system to make that easier, too.

To show the value of using its branded inks, HP offers an online demo showing the effects of aging on two versions of the same photograph: one using HPs inks, the other a third-party ink. You can upload your own image to see how it might age. It's an intriguing visual demo on how digital color photographs can age and fade.

The Epson R1900 will be available later in February, the HP PhotosmartPro B8850 in April.

—Terry Sullivan