Digital cameras: Good values for under $150

Many low-priced digital cameras are so-called compact models that are small enough to fit in a bag, if a bit bulkier than pocket-sized subcompacts. How good a value are these budget models, some of which cost less than $150?

The best are very solid values, according to an analysis of the price and performance of the compact cameras tested for our recently updated Ratings (available to subscribers).

The data is in the chart below. Using a tool called the Consumer Reports Value Index™, which we launched last month with an analysis of superzoom cameras, it plots the approximate retail price against overall score for compact cameras we've tested. Then it places groups of cameras into value zones – Higher, Medium, and Lower – based on the price and performance of all models in those categories. Products on the upper right side of the chart offer better values than those further to the left and bottom.

To use the Value Index, first roll your mouse over a circle to find out a bit more about the model it represents. To learn even more about a model, subscribers can click on its name to go to its page, which includes our expert review, a detailed breakdown of the model’s overall test results, Reliability data, user reviews, and a link to compare online prices for that model.

(More on the Value Index and our updated Ratings after the jump.)

No camera was in the highest value zone. But four models, all costing less than $150, rank as medium values: The Canon PowerShot A590 IS, Canon PowerShot A470, Samsung L100, and GE A735. The two Canons are both recommended models in our Ratings. The other two, though solid performers, lack some nuances that give the Canons an edge in our recommendations.

A number of other cameras were only slightly lower than those models in value, and had comparable prices. Four are also among the recommended models in our Ratings: The Samsung SL310W, Sony Cybershot DSC-W170, and Fujifilm FinePix F100fd, and the Canon PowerShot E1.

The upshot: Value, as reflected in this chart, provides only a rough guide to selecting a camera; it can't capture the sometimes-subtle performance advantages and features that distinguish certain models and may make them better choices for your needs.

There are, of course, some good values in subcompact cameras, as our updated Ratings will help you find. We've also recently updated our Ratings of digital SLR cameras.

For more help in buying a digital camera of any stripe, see our buying advice, which includes a video guide to the major decisions you’ll face.

The Value Index is a work-in-progress for us, and we’re working hard to improve the feature. If you have any feedback – or would like to tell us whether you got any value out of this – please share your thoughts in the Comments, below.

Comments

[rick]

these best deals are really helpful for the net savvies.... because they are in constant touch with the shopping sites... but this one is a nice post and quite helpful too

[Electrocole]

If you're looking for the best deal, don't forget to do all your comparison shopping at a site like Pricegrabber and then head over to a cash back site like Ebates before you shop. It's an easy way to get a few extra bucks back on a sale, which can oftentimes offset the tax or shipping depending on the deal itself.

It's nothing new, but if you're all about the bottom-line price, it's worth checking out at least once.

[Jack Samuels]

Just felt that I wanted everyone to know that Amazon, which is usually very good for pricing, seems to have slipped a cog.The Canon A590 PowerShot, which Consuners has listed for $110-150, is now charging a rediculously exhorbitant price of $280+,
This seems a little outrageous.

[Rick Bagley]

Can anyone give me any advice on the Canon A1000 IS? For instance, is there any difference between this and the A590 IS other than 2 more megapixels?

[Zoe Hellar]

Comprehensive write up. However, I was expecting to see many more of the Samsung models up at good value. Certainly no surprise with the Canon Powershot A470
Zoe

[chris]

I've been using this site to find out when digital cameras go on sale:

http://www.zingsale.com

So far i've found a couple nikon and canon cameras for almost 75% off. It's a free service that tracks prices of products from online stores (like amazon) and sends you an email when the price drops.